BCO
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • About
  • Capabilities
  • Clients
  • Business Writing Academy
  • Contact
  • Blots
  • Menu Menu

Should’ve or should not’ve; it’s so tricky now…

I have received two responses to last week’s blog which concerned the Intellectual Property Office approving Specsavers appropriation of ‘should’ve’ as part of its trade mark. I objected, of course, as I believe that our common language is just that: common to us all and is not for sale.

The first was from the IPO itself and parts of it are worth quoting:

“I have considered your observation but it does not tell me anything that was not known when the application was accepted, nor does it establish that the application was accepted in error. Trade marks are an Intellectual Property designed to protect a brand. Words are often registered as a trade mark in order to show that the goods or services being provided emanate from a single source of origin. However, the case has received notices of threatened opposition which may or may not lead to a formal opposition. This is a judicial process and as such I cannot pre-empt or comment on the outcome of this application. If you intend on filing a formal opposition, you must do so before the end of the opposition period. Details of the opposition process may be found here”

Translated, I believe this says that the IPO will do whatever companies want,  and it is paid to do, and if you don’t like it, please sue them and not us.

I think this is both piffle and lazy communication. Surely intellectual property is something more than words we all use?

I am extremely keen on clear, coherent communication and, in particular, its content. One essential aspect is, I believe, that everything that is said, written, broadcast or streamed is reasonable, based on common sense and best judged by the man on the Clapham Omnibus.

Who he? He is, says Wikipedia, “…a hypothetical ordinary and reasonable person, used by the courts in English law where it is necessary to decide whether a party has acted as a reasonable person would. The man on the Clapham omnibus is a reasonably educated and intelligent but nondescript person, against whom the defendant’s conduct can be measured.”

I am of the opinion that the IPO and Specsavers, who may well be within the letter of the law, are so far removed from anything that could be considered to be either reasonable or sensible that they might as well be in a different galaxy.

Far, far better is the other response I received, from an editor called Alison Harmer, who sent me a link to Groucho Marx’s response to Warner Brothers in an earlier trade mark dispute which concerned the use of the word ‘Casablanca’.

It’s clear, reasonable, hilarious, rammed with common sense and will make folk on the bus laugh out loud!

https://www.blauth.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/AAEAAQAAAAAAAAgRAAAAJDIxYTVhMzQ0LTlkNDMtNDdhNi1hNjFlLWM3NWYzMmNmMjcwNg.png 300 400 John Blauth https://www.blauth.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/BCO-logo.jpg John Blauth2016-08-24 14:41:112019-12-06 10:39:44Should’ve or should not’ve; it’s so tricky now…
Weekly Blot
  • Wild folk from the west? Maybe not…
    Wild folk from the west? Maybe not…
    In local newspaper offices, away from the conglomeration of desks around which sat a hapless crew of hacks, were treasure troves hidden in corners and cupboards....
    Read more
  • How to turn Happy Christmas into a medieval execution
    How to turn Happy Christmas into a medieval execution
    Artificial intelligence and 'natural language processing' are no substitute for taking care when writing. Maintain focus, and apply your ability to concentrate, and everything will be easy....
    Read more
  • Quack because it’s good for you
    Quack because it’s good for you
    Do you find this statement by former Google boss Eric Schmidt alarming: “We don’t need you to type at all. We know where you are. We know where you’ve been. We can more or less know what you’re thinking about.”...
    Read more
BWA logo

Business Writing Academy - BWA - is a people-driven training resource for companies and individuals who want to be understood across the whole world.

© Copyright | Terms & Conditions | Thoughtfully built by Thinkanew Media | Privacy policy
  • Link to LinkedIn
Link to: We should’ve stopped them; thankfully we still can Link to: We should’ve stopped them; thankfully we still can We should’ve stopped them; thankfully we still can Link to: A well edited sentence is a thing of beauty Link to: A well edited sentence is a thing of beauty A well edited sentence is a thing of beauty
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top